Tailwater — Fly Selection
What Flies to Use on the Toccoa Tailwater
The Toccoa tailwater is defined by its dry fly fishing. More so than
any other North Georgia tailwater, this river rewards anglers who can
identify hatches and present dry flies accurately. These are the
patterns that produce fish consistently.
The Quill Gordon is the opening act of the Toccoa's spring hatch
season and one of the most anticipated hatches in North Georgia.
It hatches on cool afternoons in March and April when water
temperatures climb into the mid-50s. Fish the parachute version
in the slower runs and pool tails where fish rise methodically
during the hatch window. A size 14 in gray-brown is the standard.
When you see quill gordons in the air on the Toccoa the fish
know it before you do.
Sizes: 14, 16 — Colors: Gray/Brown
The march brown is a large mayfly that hatches in April and May
on the Toccoa and draws aggressive surface takes from fish that
have been selective all winter. A size 12–14 comparadun or
parachute in brown-tan covers the hatch well. Fish it in the
riffles and runs during the mid-afternoon hatch window. The
march brown's size makes it one of the most visible and exciting
dry fly hatches of the spring season.
Sizes: 12, 14 — Colors: Brown/Tan
The sulphur hatch is the peak of the Toccoa's dry fly season.
Evening hatches in May and June bring every fish in the river
to the surface and the fishing can be nothing short of exceptional
when conditions align. A size 16–18 parachute in yellow-cream
matches the dun stage. Fish the emerger version just subsurface
when fish are sipping rather than slashing. The sulphur hatch
is the reason serious dry fly anglers plan Toccoa trips in May.
Sizes: 16, 18 — Colors: Yellow/Cream
Caddis are present on the Toccoa from early spring through late
fall in multiple species — black caddis in winter and early spring,
gray caddis in spring, olive caddis in May and June, tan caddis
in summer, and october caddis in fall. The elk hair caddis in
appropriate size and color covers most situations. Fish it in the
riffles and runs where caddis concentrate and don't be afraid to
skitter it across the surface — caddis are active flies and the
fish know it.
Sizes: 14, 16, 18 — Colors: Black, Gray, Olive, Tan
The light cahill is one of the most productive patterns on the
Toccoa from June through October. It hatches in the evenings
throughout summer and into fall, bringing fish to the surface
during the last two hours of light. A size 14–16 parachute in
cream-yellow is the standard. The light cahill is the evening
fly on the Toccoa — if you're planning a summer trip, plan to
be on the water for the last two hours of daylight.
Sizes: 14, 16 — Colors: Cream/Yellow
The october caddis is one of the largest caddis species and its
hatch on the Toccoa in October is a genuine event. Size 8–10
orange-bodied elk hair caddis or stimulator patterns draw aggressive
surface takes from fish that have been feeding on smaller flies
all season. The sheer size of the fly relative to what fish have
been seeing makes for explosive strikes. If you can be on the
Toccoa in October during a good october caddis hatch you'll
understand why guides call this their favorite month on the river.
Sizes: 8, 10 — Colors: Orange/Tan
Even on a river as hatch-rich as the Toccoa, midges are a constant
food source and the zebra midge is a reliable producer year-round.
It's the go-to pattern when nothing is visibly hatching and fish
are holding deep in the pools. Fish it under an indicator through
the slower runs and pools. In winter when midge hatches are the
primary activity a size 20–22 zebra midge is often the only fly
you need.
Sizes: 18, 20, 22 — Colors: Black/Silver, Red/Silver
The woolly bugger is the search pattern and the big fish pattern
on the Toccoa. Strip it through deep pools to cover water and
find aggressive fish, or dead-drift it through runs as a large
nymph imitation. In fall when brown trout are moving for the spawn
a heavily weighted black or olive bugger stripped through holding
water produces some of the largest fish of the year. Low light
conditions — early morning, overcast days, dusk — are consistently
the most productive times for streamer fishing on this river.
Sizes: 6, 8, 10 — Colors: Black, Olive, Brown